| 2025 |
Griffin Kirn |
LHP |
NCBWA |
3rd |
| 2024 |
Derek Clark |
LHP |
D1Baseball |
3rd |
| 2024 |
Derek Clark |
LHP |
NCBWA |
3rd |
| 2024 |
JJ Wetherholt |
SS |
Perfect Game |
3rd |
| 2023 |
JJ Wetherholt |
2B |
D1Baseball |
1st |
| 2023 |
JJ Wetherholt |
2B |
Baseball America |
1st |
| 2023 |
JJ Wetherholt |
2B |
Collegiate Baseball |
1st |
| 2023 |
JJ Wetherholt |
2B |
NCBWA |
1st |
| 2023 |
JJ Wetherholt |
2B |
Perfect Game |
1st |
| 2023 |
JJ Wetherholt |
2B |
College Baseball Foundation |
1st |
| 2023 |
JJ Wetherholt |
2B |
ABCA |
1st |
| 2022 |
Trey Braithwaite |
RHP |
NCBWA |
3rd |
| 2019 |
Alek Manoah |
RHP |
NCBWA |
1st |
| 2019 |
Alek Manoah |
RHP |
Baseball America |
1st |
| 2019 |
Alek Manoah |
RHP |
D1Baseball |
1st |
| 2019 |
Alek Manoah |
RHP |
Collegiate Baseball |
1st |
| 2019 |
Alek Manoah |
RHP |
Perfect Game |
1st |
| 2019 |
Alek Manoah |
RHP |
ABCA |
1st |
| 2019 |
Alek Manoah |
RHP |
College Baseball Foundation |
1st |
| 2018 |
Kyle Gray |
2B |
ABCA |
3rd |
| 2017 |
Braden Zarbnisky |
RHP/OF |
NCBWA |
3rd |
| 2013 |
Harrison Musgrave |
LHP |
Louisville Slugger |
2nd |
| 2013 |
Harrison Musgrave |
LHP |
College Baseball Insider |
Honorable Mention |
| 2010 |
Jedd Gyorko |
SS |
NCBWA |
1st |
| 2010 |
Jedd Gyorko |
SS |
Louisville Slugger |
2nd |
| 2010 |
Jedd Gyorko |
SS |
ABCA |
2nd |
| 2010 |
Jedd Gyorko |
SS |
Baseball America |
2nd |
| 2009 |
Vince Belnome |
2B |
College Baseball Insider |
3rd |
| 2009 |
Jedd Gyorko |
SS |
Louisville Slugger |
2nd |
| 2009 |
Jedd Gyorko |
SS |
NCBWA |
3rd |
| 2008 |
Jedd Gyorko |
2B |
NCBWA |
2nd |
| 2008 |
Tyler Kuhn |
SS |
NCBWA |
3rd |
| 2008 |
Tyler Kuhn |
SS |
ABCA |
3rd |
| 2007 |
Justin Jenkins |
LF |
Collegiate Baseball |
3rd |
| 2007 |
Justin Jenkins |
LF |
Louisville Slugger |
3rd |
| 2007 |
Justin Jenkins |
LF |
NCBWA |
3rd |
| 1998 |
Joe McNamee |
LF |
ABCA |
3rd |
| 1997 |
Chris Enochs |
RHP |
Collegiate Baseball |
1st |
| 1997 |
Chris Enochs |
RHP |
ABCA |
1st |
| 1997 |
Chris Enochs |
RHP |
Baseball America |
2nd |
| 1997 |
Chris Enochs |
RHP |
The Sporting News |
2nd |
| 1997 |
Chris Enochs |
RHP |
NCBWA |
2nd |
| 1994 |
Mark Landers |
1B |
ABCA |
2nd |
| 1994 |
Mark Landers |
1B |
Collegiate Baseball |
3rd |
| 1994 |
Mark Landers |
1B |
NCBWA |
3rd |
| 1964 |
Bill Marovic |
CF |
ABCA |
1st |
| 1962 |
Joe Hatalla |
2B |
ABCA |
3rd |
| 1961 |
Tom Shafer |
P |
Amateur Baseball Federation |
2nd |
| 1961 |
Ed Tekavec |
3B |
ABCA |
2nd |
