Thirty years later, when Gogolak was kicking those long, majestic field goals for the Buffalo Bills, teams finally began to see the true value of having a kicking specialist.
The New York Giants, stung by the publicity the American Football League New York Jets were getting with their $400,000 quarterback Joe Namath, broke an unwritten rule between the NFL and AFL of not negotiating with its free agent players by signing Gogolak to a three-year contract.
Gogolak’s surprise signing began a bidding war for players that ultimately led to the two leagues merging in 1970.
The publicity Gogolak got for his soccer-style kicking quickly filtered down to the college ranks where teams began to consider making room on their rosters for kicking specialists.
At West Virginia, for many years its place-kicking was a haphazard exercise at best. Field goals were rarely tried and when they were, it was usually done as a last resort. Extra points were the responsibility of the team’s best athlete, such as Ira Errett Rogers in the late teens or Pete Barnum during the mid-1920s.
Many games were decided because of made (and missed) extra points.
For decades, whenever the Mountaineers lined up to try an extra point it was done so with bated breath.
Then in 1948 came little Gene Simmons, a 5-foot-7-inch, 140-pound halfback from Elkins who once made 15 straight drop kicks while playing at Elkins High.
Coach Dud DeGroot understood the value of place-kicking during his days coaching professional football, and he found a spot on the team for Simmons as an extra halfback. There was not much Simmons could contribute to the team as a runner, but DeGroot figured he could be helpful when inserted into the game to kick field goals and extra points.
Simmons’ short third-quarter field goal was the deciding score in West Virginia’s big 16-14 victory over Maryland that led to the Mountaineers earning a 1949 Sun Bowl bid.
Simmons successfully booted 79-of-90 extra point tries and four field goals during his career for a then-school record 91 points.